Johnathan Shillingford’s Controversial Presence on Below Deck Mediterranean
Johnathan Shillingford, a chef on “Below Deck Mediterranean,” has become a contentious figure in the ninth season of the show due to his exaggerated persona and questionable culinary skills. Notably, he once came dangerously close to harming a guest during a charter. His failure to adhere to the preference sheet and fulfill his duties has left both the guests and his team dissatisfied. In a recent episode, instead of serving crème brûlée as requested, he offered cookie ice cream, leading to suspicions that his presence on the show might be a strategic move by producers to heighten the drama.
Chef Johnathan’s Social Media Antics
Recently, Johnathan shared a meme on Instagram, featuring a photo of himself exuding confidence with a smirk and a gesture of brushing off his shoulders. The accompanying text stated, “me hyping up my own cooking,” alongside his catchphrase, “flavour flavour, okay, okurrrr.” Although he did not explicitly label the post, it served to flaunt his excessive self-assurance in his cooking talents. This post likely aimed to resonate with those who mirror his egotistical demeanor while subtly addressing his critics on the show.
The Implications of Johnathan’s Bold Attitude for Below Deck Mediterranean
Unfazed by Potential Consequences





Johnathan’s recent Instagram activity reveals a level of arrogance and self-absorption that suggests he is unconcerned about the possibility of losing his job. This confidence may stem from an inflated belief in his culinary abilities, despite his numerous blunders. Throughout the series, he has made critical errors such as ignoring dietary preferences, opting for sleep over fulfilling late-night snack requests, and endangering a guest by serving raw fish despite known dietary restrictions.
Producer-Driven Drama?

20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
His Instagram post also fuels speculation that he might be a deliberate addition by producers to stir up drama. Despite being one of the least effective crew members in the recent history of the show, he remains aboard Captain Sandy Yawn’s yacht, seemingly untouchable. This lends some credence to the theory that he was placed on the show to provoke and entertain through his flamboyant behavior and audacious attitude. It remains to be seen if Johnathan will return in future seasons.
Our Perspective on Chef Johnathan Shillingford’s Self-Promotion
The Need for Professional Culinary Training
Johnathan’s shortcomings as both a crew member and a chef raise questions about his initial hiring for “Below Deck.” His evident lack of skills suggests he would benefit from formal culinary education to enhance his capabilities. Without improving his techniques and attitude, he is unlikely to succeed in a high-pressure culinary environment. Perhaps he should consider refining his skills or pursuing a different path, such as catering for smaller, more intimate events.
“Below Deck Mediterranean” airs Mondays at 9 p.m. ET on Bravo and is available for streaming the following day on Peacock.
Source: Johnathan Shillingford/Instagram

Below Deck Mediterranean
- Reality-TV
Below Deck Mediterranean is a Bravo reality television series that follows a crew that works aboard a gigantic superyacht during the busy season. The show highlights the challenges of the crew as they serve their high-end clientele. Each season tackles new locations, such as Greece, Croatia, Italy, and France, with some repeating.